Will David Cook Win it?

Up until now I haven't chosen favorites in this competition but after David Cook performed Billie Jean I was seriously amazed! His solid and unique performances over the past few weeks make him the most impressive contestant so far! His take on Billie Jean was brilliant and he deserves to be in the top 3 and possibly deserves to win it all!

As far as the other contestants, Michael John's performance tonight was pretty good and Brooke's was OK too but I wasn't impressed with the remaining performances. Were you? Who were your favorites of the night? Any surprises?

In other Idol related news, it appears that the adorable Josiah Leming has landed a record deal with Warner Bros. He totally deserves it. Go Josiah! I'll be on the lookout for his CD.

So, Who's Going Home Tonight on American Idol?

Here it is almost time for one of the top 12 to be voted out and I'm just now doing a recap of last night's performances. Anyway, I'll make this really quick without the full run down as I usually do. Instead I'll put the hopeful idols in order from 1-12, 1 being the best and 12 being the worst.

Here goes...

My favorites of the night were :

1. David Cook
2. Jason Castro
3. Michael Johns
4. Brooke White

Good but not good enough last night:
5. Carly Smithson
6. David Archuletta
7. Chikezie

The forgettable but solid performances:
8. Ramiele Malubay
9. Syesha Mercado

Not good at all last night:
10. David Hernandez - I'm usually a fan :(
11. Amanda Overmyer
12. Kristy Lee Cook

So, it's easy to figure out who I think should go home based on my scale above.

Who I think should go home: Kristy Lee Cook or Amanda Overmyer.
Who will probably go home: Syesha, David H. or Ramiele

The best of the night: David Cook by far!!!

So, with all that being said, who do think is going home? Any shockers tonight?